How Do I Know Which Supplements I Actually Need?

Quick answer

The best place to start is your own goals, diet, and health history rather than a trending list. Supplements are not one-size-fits-all, and label quality also varies, since a 2022 study found that more than half of the immune supplements it tested had labels that did not match what was inside. A short, structured look at your needs, plus products from brands with strong quality testing, keeps it simple.

Taking a lot of supplements and not sure what's worth it?

Send me your list for a free supplement review. There is no cost and no appointment needed.

Get my free supplement review

Key takeaways

The best starting point for choosing supplements is your own goals, diet and health history rather than a trending list.

Label quality varies, and one study found that many immune supplements tested did not match their labels.

Before buying, it helps to ask what goal you are supporting, whether your diet already covers it, and whether the product is third-party tested.

Walk into any store or scroll any feed and you will see dozens of supplements that promise to help. It is easy to end up with a cabinet full of bottles and no clear idea of which ones are worth taking.

Why is choosing supplements so confusing?

Supplements are sold with a huge range of claims, and what works for a friend may have nothing to do with your own needs. Your diet, sleep, activity, medications, and life stage all shape what makes sense for you.

Are supplement labels always accurate?

Not always. In a 2022 study published in JAMA Network Open, researchers tested 30 supplements marketed for immune support. Only 13 had labels that matched what the analysis found. Many of the others listed ingredients that were not detected, and some contained ingredients that were not on the label at all.

That is one reason I recommend practitioner-grade products from brands that publish third-party testing.

What questions should I ask before I buy?

Ask what goal you are trying to support, whether your diet already covers it, whether the supplement could interact with any medication you take, and whether the brand tests its products independently. If you are pregnant, nursing, or managing a health condition, check with your provider first.

Is there a quick way to narrow it down?

My free Supplement Match quiz takes a couple of minutes and suggests where to focus based on your goals and routine, so you are not guessing.

Not sure where to start? The free quiz takes about two minutes.

Take the free Supplement Match quiz

Questions to bring to your clinician

These questions can help you get the most out of your next visit.

Which of my current supplements are truly worth keeping for my goals?

Could my current supplement list interact with any of my current medications or other supplements?

Would any labs or health history details help us decide whether my current supplement list makes sense for me?

How would we tell whether my current supplement list is a good fit for me, and when should we check in again?

What the research shows

Labels are not always accurate. In a 2022 JAMA Network Open study by Crawford and colleagues, researchers bought 30 popular immune-support supplements on Amazon and tested their contents. Only 13 had accurate labels. Thirteen were missing ingredients listed on the label, and nine contained substances that were not listed. The study looked at one product category at one point in time, but it shows why third-party testing matters.

Fish oil shows the same issue. In a 2015 study by Albert and colleagues, only 3 of 32 fish oil products sold in New Zealand contained the EPA and DHA amounts on their labels, and most were more oxidized than recommended. Price and expiration date did not predict quality.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know what supplements I need?

Start with your goals, diet, medications, and health history. A structured questionnaire or a conversation with a provider can help narrow it down.

Are supplement labels accurate?

Not always. A 2022 study found that only 13 of 30 immune supplements tested had accurate labels.

Should I check with a provider before starting supplements?

Yes, especially if you take medications, are pregnant or nursing, or have a health condition.

Sources

  1. Crawford C, Avula B, Lindsey AT, et al. Analysis of Select Dietary Supplement Products Marketed to Support or Boost the Immune System. JAMA Netw Open 2022. PMID: 35947382. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35947382/
  2. Albert BB, Derraik JG, Cameron-Smith D, et al. Fish oil supplements in New Zealand are highly oxidised and do not meet label content of n-3 PUFA. Sci Rep 2015. PMID: 25604397. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25604397/
  3. Crawford C, et al. Analysis of select dietary supplement products marketed to support or boost the immune system. JAMA Netw Open. 2022. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35947382/

This page shares general educational information and is not medical advice. These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Talk with your healthcare provider before starting a supplement, especially if you take medications, are pregnant or nursing, or have a health condition.


Looking for practitioner-grade options?

The catalog carries third-party-tested, practitioner-grade supplements from brands Dr. Kneessi uses in practice.

See practitioner-grade options in the catalogNot sure what fits? Take the Supplement Quiz →

Table of Contents

Picture of Dr. Ryan Kneessi, ND

Dr. Ryan Kneessi, ND

Dr. Ryan Kneessi, ND, is a naturopathic doctor in Odenton, Maryland, who practices functional medicine.

Disclosure: I earn a margin on some products purchased through my Fullscript store, and I only recommend products I would use in my own practice.

Free Supplement Quiz
Answer a few questions to see which supplement types may fit your goals, plus safety notes to review.
Take the Supplement Match QuizShop My Fullscript Store