By Dr. Ryan Kneessi, ND

People often ask me why I recommend some supplements and pass on others that look almost the same on the shelf. The honest answer is that I look past the front of the bottle. On this page I walk you through the questions I ask before a product earns a place in my Fullscript catalog, so you can use the same thinking when you shop on your own.

Browse My Supplement Guide by Goal   Take the Supplement Match Quiz

Why I am careful about quality

In the United States, dietary supplements do not need FDA approval before they are sold. The company that makes a supplement is responsible for making sure it is safe and that its label is truthful, and the FDA steps in mainly after a product is already on the market. The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements explains this clearly in its consumer guide, and it is the main reason I do my own homework on every brand.

Label accuracy is a real concern, too. When researchers tested 25 melatonin gummy products sold in the US, most did not contain the amount of melatonin listed on the label, and some contained far more than the label stated. That study is a good reminder that what is printed on the bottle and what is inside it are not always the same.

1. Third-party testing

The first thing I look for is independent testing. I favor companies that test their raw ingredients and finished products for identity, potency and purity, and that are willing to share those results or a certificate of analysis when asked. Independent programs such as USP Verified and NSF/ANSI 173 certification are helpful signs, because an outside organization checks that the product contains what the label says and meets limits for contaminants. Not every good product carries one of these seals, so when a brand does not have one, I look for clear evidence of its own testing instead.

2. Ingredient form and quality

The form of a nutrient matters, because different forms are absorbed and used differently. Magnesium is a good example, since magnesium glycinate, citrate and oxide behave differently in the body and suit different people. I also look at where an herbal ingredient comes from, which part of the plant is used and whether the extract is standardized, so that one bottle is consistent with the next. Finally, I check that the dose is in line with what has been studied, rather than a tiny sprinkled-in amount or a dose far higher than the research supports.

3. Transparent labels

I want to be able to read a label and know exactly what I am taking. That means every ingredient and its amount is listed, and I steer away from proprietary blends that hide the amount of each ingredient behind a single total. I also check the other ingredients, such as fillers, colors and sweeteners, and I look for clear allergen information, so that people with sensitivities can choose with confidence.

4. Manufacturing standards

Every supplement company that sells in the US is required to follow the FDA’s Current Good Manufacturing Practice rules for dietary supplements, found in 21 CFR Part 111. These rules cover how products are made, tested, packaged, labeled and stored. I look for companies that take this seriously and go further, for example with outside audits of their facilities and consistent batch testing. I also like that Fullscript sources products directly from the manufacturers and stores them under controlled conditions, which helps protect quality on the way to your door.

5. Fit for the person

Even the best-made product is only a good choice if it fits the person taking it. I think about other supplements and medications someone is already taking, possible interactions and whether a simpler option would do the job. I would always rather you take a few well-made basics consistently than a long list of products you are not sure you need.

How to use my picks

If you would like to see the products I trust, my supplement guide by goal organizes them by topic, with plain-language guides for each one. If you are not sure where to begin, the Supplement Match Quiz takes a few minutes and points you toward a starting point. You can also go straight to my Fullscript catalog and browse on your own.

Sources

  • NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Dietary Supplements: What You Need to Know. ods.od.nih.gov
  • Cohen PA, Avula B, Wang YH, Katragunta K, Khan I. Quantity of Melatonin and CBD in Melatonin Gummies Sold in the US. JAMA. 2023. PubMed 37097362
  • Current Good Manufacturing Practice in Manufacturing, Packaging, Labeling, or Holding Operations for Dietary Supplements, 21 CFR Part 111. eCFR

Written by Dr. Ryan Kneessi, ND

This page is for education only and is not a medical visit. These statements have not been evaluated by the FDA. Products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Some supplements interact with medications, so please check with your prescriber or pharmacist before starting anything new, especially if you are pregnant, nursing, or managing a health condition.

Disclosure: I earn a margin on some products purchased through my Fullscript store, and I only recommend products I would use in my own practice.

Text Dr. KneessiCall
Please don’t include health details by text.